Book Club Experience - The Chaos Machine
This book was something
that felt like reading a history book of recent events. It was a long read and
was a struggle to get through, though I was able to finish the book in time for
the book club. It was also interesting as to how everyone interacted with each
other. The conversation felt very productive since everyone felt familiar with
each other since they had been meeting for a while, and I am very new to the
group.
Who is asking the questions, is there a leader or do people take turns?
There was a librarian
leader to help lead and guide the discussion, but mainly she had included her thoughts
and guided the conversation to keep it on track with the book, as well as
letting others talk about their real-life experiences with technology and the
platforms trying to garner are use time on them. Mainly, we answered her questions
that she created for us to answer, although it was all done through natural conversation
progression, and everyone each had an opportunity to talk since the leader
would try to prompt someone else to talk if they hadn’t taken the opportunity
to talk yet during the conversation.
If there is a leader, does the leader answer the questions as well or let the attendees respond first?
The leader allowed all the
attendees to answer the questions and included what they thought while talking
since this book was mainly about how we connected and felt with the book since
technology heavily connects our lives. The questions that she had come up with
were also related to how we felt, as well as helping us understand that book
better about the different ways that social media has affected our lives, as
well as the lives of many others around the world.
What type of questions are asked? Any involving just yes or no answers?
The main questions were
to try to prompt conversation and to have a talk about social media, how it
affects each person individually, and how it can change how we as humans exist
in this world. All the questions involved more prompting to add to the conversation
and were never left with just a yes or no answer.
Do all attendees actively participate?
The leader tried to make
sure that everyone had an opportunity to communicate. Everyone had spoken
during the meeting, but the leader would try to prompt the quieter people to
add more to the conversation to add more perspective from themselves about the
book and social media in general. Having several different people from all
different age ranges certainly helped to give perspective, and being the
youngest one there, I talked about how I grew up with social media. It was better
since everyone was active and willing to talk and have an easy-flowing
conversation between all the participants without anyone getting angry or
shouting.
Do any attendees swoop in and steal all the spotlight?
Some of the participants
had more to say than others, but it was a relatively balanced conversation.
About two to three had talked more about their experiences and the book than
the others, but everyone still had the opportunity to talk and communicate with
one another.
What is the atmosphere of the discussion, and where is it taking place?
The atmosphere of the
discussion was super warm and welcoming, even with a topic as tough as social
media and how it affects the human mind and the world we live in. The club took
place at the library in one of the conference rooms, a bit more secluded and
warmer. Overall, it was a nice and comfortable atmosphere that anyone would
feel inclined to participate in without feeling like they are necessarily being
judged by others, but willing to be heard and understood to the best of their
abilities.
Are snacks or drinks provided?
There weren’t any snacks
or drinks provided, but one of the club members had come in with a bunch of
cookies that she had baked with her fiancé. They were really good, but not many
others took that many cookies. She went home with most of the cookies she had
brought. It seems that this club doesn’t do food all that much.
What types of books does this book club normally discuss?
The book club I participated
in discusses many different kinds of books. They talk about fiction,
nonfiction, and young adult books. They try to have several different kinds of
books to make the experience of the book club more interesting by offering something
new and exciting each month. This is likely so they can expand and include
others who are more inclined to read a specific kind of book and to help them
find new people in the community who also like to read the same kind of books
as them.
I think the leader was smart in trying to get the quieter people to participate. I know sometimes, at least for me, it is hard to do so especially if it's a new environment. I also love that the book club you joined discusses a variety of topics. I feel like this helps expand interests and helps people try new genres they wouldn't have otherwise.
ReplyDeleteThis book sounds like a great choice for a book club! I feel like nonfiction isn't as popular in book clubs as fiction, but there's a lot of great discussion that can come from a timely nonfiction book, and everyone has an opinion on social media.
ReplyDeleteI'll be honest, I felt I had lucked out with a book club that focused on fiction instead of nonfiction. I wonder which would be more popular with a given audience?
ReplyDeleteI love when book clubs include non-fiction titles because as you said, it feels a little like a current events talk! With this title specifically it seems like there would be so much to talk about and to get people talking to each other, even if they aren't necessarily only talking about the book! As someone who loves non-fiction, this sounds like a meeting that I would have enjoyed attending!
ReplyDeleteGreat write up! It sounds like this book club is a well oiled machine! What a tough (and relevant) book too!
ReplyDeleteWell Taryn, You've convinced me to read another book. It's fine. I'm only reading three at once right now anyway. I agree with Abigail that nonfiction is not as popular in book clubs.
ReplyDelete